Skip to header Skip to main navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer
englishfrançaisdeutschitalianosvenskaespañoltürkçenederlandsportuguêsΕλληνικά
русскийहिन्दीفارسی한국어日本語filipino中文বাংলাmagyarsuomi
Home
International Communist Current
Workers of the world, unite!

Main navigation

      • Britain
      • India
      • United States
      • Rest of the world
    • By post
  • What is the ICC?
    • Introduction
    • Basic Positions
    • Platform
    • Manifesto (1975)
    • Manifesto (1991)
    • History of the ICC
      • 20 years of the ICC
      • 30 years of the ICC
    • What is the communist left?
    • ICConline
      • 1990s
      • 2000s
      • 2010s
      • 2020s
    • International Review
      • 1970s - 1 to 19
      • 1980s - 20 to 59
      • 1990s - 60 to 99
      • 2000s - 100 to 139
      • 2010s - 140 to 163
      • 2020s - 164 to ...
    • World Revolution
      • 1970s
      • 1990s
      • 2000s - 231 to 330
      • 2010s - 331 to 384
      • 2020s - 385 to ...
    • Internationalism
      • 1990s
      • 2000s
      • 2010s
    • Internasyonalismo
      • 2000s
      • 2010s
    • Communist Internationalist
      • 2000s
      • 2010s
    • Dutch and German Communist Left
    • The Italian Communist Left 1926-45
    • Communist Organisations and Class Consciousness
    • Nation or Class?
    • The Period of Transition
    • Decadence of Capitalism
    • Unions Against the Working Class
    • Left Wing of the Turkish Communist Party
    • Manifesto on the October revolution
    • World War I
    • Subscriptions
    • Buy from ICC
    • Buy offline

The evolution of the British situation since World War 2 (part two)

Breadcrumb

  • Home
  • International Review 1970s: 1-19
  • 1979 - 16 to 19
  • International Review no.19 - 4th quarter 1979

The Labor Party: Government Team and Loyal Opposition

9. The party of the bourgeoisie which corresponds most closely to the overall needs of British national capital -- not just in the current conjunctural crisis but in the whole epoch of decadence -- is the Labor Party. Its specific structure and orientation are best suited to deal with the requirements of British capital, particularly since World War II, in relation to the needs for:

-- the statification of the economy

-- the support of the western bloc

-- the containment of the struggle of the working class.

While it would be a mistake not to recognize the flexibility of the Conservative Party, a product of the maturity developed as the most experienced party of the oldest capitalist nation-state, the experience of the recent period has only underlined the role of the Labor Party -- for the last decade has produced a profound economic crisis, an intensification of inter-imperialist rivalry and the greatest upsurge of proletarian militancy since the last revolutionary wave. At first sight this argument may not appear to be clear-cut -since the two parties have been in power approximately 17 years apiece. But this statistic masks the two important factors:

-- the longest period of Tory rule, from 1951 to 1964, had the major objective of trying to hold the Empire/Commonwealth together as market preserves for British capital. This effort failed and such a requirement for a corresponding government will not return;

-- since the onset of the open crisis, the two occasions in which the Labor Party has been ousted from power have both been during upsurges of class struggle and when the capacity of the Labor Party and trade unions to contain the proletariat has been considerably eroded by periods when the left party had been in government office holding down their living standards. At these times the Labor Party and the unions have gone through phases of ‘opposition’ in which they tried to regroup their forces in a more effective way to meet the conditions of proletarian militancy. But even in opposition, the task of trying to derail the struggle of the working class remains predominantly with this faction of the bourgeoisie.

Thus, as we examine the evolution of the situation since 1945, we can see that the most effective defender of the national capital is the Labor Party. It is consequently the most dangerous enemy of the proletariat’s struggle.

10. When we examine the maneuvers of the parties in this period and relate them to the issues facing the bourgeoisie, we have to remember that:

-- if the differences between the Labor and Conservative Parties are not as great as their propaganda tries to make out nonetheless they do correspond to different visions of the program for British capital.

For example the Labor Party is far more committed to state control over the economy than the Tories who retain a greater loyalty to particularistic interests in society; Labor has a far stronger connection to the union apparatus which the Tories can’t replicate;

-- the program defended by each of the parties are not static, but change in response to the pressure imposed on the national capital and the options presented in a given period. This pressure comes from immediate circumstances as well as from the long-term effects of the permanent crisis of capitalism. For example, with regard to increasing statification (which is now a historical necessity for all national capitals) the Conservatives have shifted far to the left of the position they had, say, ten years ago;

-- each party has several currents or factions within it, reflecting different programs for dealing with the problems of the national capital. No matter how monolithic a bourgeois party tries to make itself out to be, internal faction fights go on all the time. Shifts in party policies can therefore also be achieved through the assertion of one faction at the expense of another;

-- both Labor and the Tories are constrained by the parliamentary framework and the electoral system which require them to construct ‘appeals’ to different sections of the electorate. This is a burden on the capacity of the bourgeoisie to get the governing faction it wants, though in Britain’s case it has provided an important source of mystification against the working class. However, the bourgeoisie is willing and able to suspend the electoral charade when the need is felt -- as it did, for example, between 1939-45, with the formation of the national coalition.

11. At the beginning; of World War II the British bourgeoisie had in power the very faction of the Conservative Party which had tried to avoid the war. It fell with the end of the ‘phoney war’ and was replaced by an alliance of those sections of the bourgeoisie which saw their primary task being to stop German expansionism. The coalition government led by Churchill included a substantial representation from the Labor Party for two main reasons:

-- the Labor Party had the necessary capacity to organize and impose the domination of the state over all aspects of the economy, and to subordinate the economy to the needs of war production;

-- only the Labor Party had the ability to mobilize the working class for the austerity and high rates of exploitation demanded for war production, and for conscription into the army.

Despite the majority of Conservatives in the government, the real weight of the organization of society for the war was borne by the Labor Party and the trade union apparatus. And, indeed, even the fall of Chamberlain and the Conservative’s choice of Churchill to replace him were due, in considerable measure, to the efforts of the Labor Party.

The war was prosecuted with several objectives, most of which were shared with the US: to defeat Germany and Japan and to contain the Russian threat to Europe. However, the coalition government resisted the threat represented by the US to the British economy and to its colonies -- the British bourgeoisie did not want to become a dependency of the US. A measure of this resistance is given by the fact that, despite all the efforts of the US bourgeoisie, it was not until the Suez crisis of 1956 that Britain finally and openly collapsed as a world power.

With the Labor Party playing such a strong role in the coalition, the bourgeoisie was much more able to see the need for a program for the aftermath of the war to defuse any potential working class struggle; the bourgeoisie had drawn the lessons from the consequences of the unplanned end to World War I. The Beveridge Report was thus commissioned to continue and further statification while appearing to offer palliatives aimed specifically at the working class.

12. The Labor government under Atlee, elected in 1945, corresponded to the situation immediately following the war. Faced with a profound dislocation of the economy it maintained many of the war-time measures to continue the supply of workers and raw materials between industries. It implemented a massive nationalization program which included the Bank of England, coal, gas, electricity, iron and steel as well as sections of many other industries, Externally, the government recognized that there would be no reversal of the new world order -- the US was master of its bloc – and that the days were numbered for the retention of the Empire, since the economic and military cost of preserving it could not be sustained. The granting of independence to India was therefore not such a fundamental wrench as it would have been for sections of the Conservative Party. Although it tried to minimize the worst of American economic measures against Britain, Labor was well suited to the implementation of the austerity measures demanded by the US. By working together with the union apparatus it was able to hold down the workers’ living standards for years. To the workers it presented itself, first of all, as the party of ‘full employment’.

The Labor government was only just returned in 1950 and fell from power in the election held the following year. This electoral turning to the right was a result of several factors:

-- the reconstruction was helping to stipulate the economy and tended to strengthen the resistance of sectors of the bourgeoisie to plans for further nationalizations and for possible losses of other colonies;

-- the successful containment of the workers by the Labor government had removed the fear of major social upheaval from the bourgeoisie as a whole;

-- resistance to the US’ economic policies towards Britain was growing. This acted against the Atlee administration which was associated with their implementation.

13. The next thirteen years in which the Conservative Party remained in power corresponded to the years of major economic benefit from the post-war reconstruction -- although there was a need for a succession of deflationary and inflationary measures to maintain economic equilibrium. In addition, there was a general quiescence of the proletariat: the class struggle was dampened by the new-found capacity of the bourgeoisie to draw palliatives from the relative health of the economy. The policies of the Conservatives towards the economy had become more appropriate to the period because of the shift in the party towards a more realistic acceptance of a higher level of state capitalism, marked by the adoption of the ‘Industrial Charter’ in 1947. Sections of the party who had drawn up this document were by this time prominent in the party, first under Churchill, then under Eden, and finally under Macmillan who had most clearly represented the state capitalist tendency inside the party as far back as the thirties.

Macmillan also represented the tendency in the party which saw that the Empire could not be maintained in the same old way, and had argued for a reassessment of the measures needed to keep the former colonies under British economic domination. This tendency was therefore brought to power after Eden’s Suez intervention demonstra­ted the impossibility of holding on to the colo­nies. One of the main tasks was to draw up a program for colonial independence, and this goal was underlined in Macmillan’s 1961 Cape Town speech on the ‘wind of change’ blowing through Africa.

On the question of ‘Europe or the Commonwealth’, the bourgeoisie still tried to have it both ways, attempting to get access to the markets being built up in Europe while maintaining the system of Commonwealth preferences. Though the Conser­vative government favored staying outside the European Economic Community at the time of its formation in 1957, by the sixties it was opening negotiations to join since the benefits of the old Commonwealth trade were disappearing before its eyes. But it was not until the seventies that leading factions of the bourgeoisie felt that Britain’s economic position had weakened to the extent that it had to join the EEC, an essential tool for the organization of a substan­tial proportion of the western bloc’s economic activity.

By the early sixties, it was clear that the Tor­ies had no further policy to stimulate the economy and make it more productive, something which was becoming more urgent in the face of growing German and Japanese competition. There was also, in the second half of the 1950s, a growing resis­tance by workers to government attempts to impose ‘wage restraints’ and increase exploitation.

Though the level of class struggle was generally far lower than in the late sixties/early seventies, the bourgeoisie was becoming alarmed at the increase in wildcat strikes.

14. A Labor government under Wilson was brought to power in 1964 to deal with these problems. It aimed to pursue a far more rigorous state intervention towards the economy than the Cons­ervative government. It had limited goals in regard to outright nationalization (mainly a re-nationalization of the steel industry) but a greater commitment towards overall state planning and direction of economic resources to build up the productivity of British capital. It also aimed to tighten control over the national wage bill by pulling unions and employers’ organiza­tions under a state planning umbrella, and to deal with the rising tide of wildcat strikes through legislation on the trade unions.

To take part of the burden of military expendi­ture off the economy, Wilson ended the maintenance of most of the British military capabilities east of Suez. Like the previous Attlee govern­ment, Wilson had a positive orientation towards the US, shown in his support for the US’ inter­vention in South-East Asia.

The grandiose plans of this administration for the regeneration of the British economy crashed in the face of two major problems:

-- the runs on sterling, which had been a regular feature of British economic life since the war, culminated in a massive onslaught which the bour­geoisie could not withstand. This resulted in the sterling devaluation of 1967 which not only ended sterling’s role as a major reserve currency, but in fact heralded the new period of open crisis for world capital;

  • the eruption of a wave of proletarian militancy not seen for over forty years and which signified a qualitative change in the nature of the period.

The years which followed saw a profound disruption inside the Labor government, the Labor Party, between the government and the unions, etc. Consequently, at the time when the bourgeoisie most needed this apparatus to work together to contain the intensifying struggle of the workers, they were in disarray. The Labor government fell in 1970 only to be replaced by the Heath administration which was even more inept.

To explain how this disarray came about, and how the Labor Party and the unions regrouped their forces between 1970 and 1974 in order to again confront the class, it is necessary to examine the major tendencies inside the party and the union apparatus.

15. Because of its historical origins the Labor Party ‘system’ is a complex amalgam of institu­tions tied together at different levels with links of various strengths. At the annual conferences the main organizations represented are the constituency parties and the trade unions, and they and the Parliamentary Labor Party (PIP) have places on the National Executive Committee (NEC). Outside this framework, in Parliament, the Labor MPs elect the leader and certain others, with the composition of the cabi­net (or Shadow cabinet) being determined by the leader. Direct links also exist between the NEC and the PLP and, since the early 1970s, between the government and the TUC through a liaison committee. (Of the Labor MPs a significant proportion are in fact sponsored by trade unions).

On the ideological level we can broadly split the Labor Party into two major groupings -- the left and the right - although in reality neither of these is constant nor homogeneous. Though subject to variation the major differences in orientation between the two can be outlined as follows:

-- regarding the economy, the left has tended to push for the acceleration of statification in the most direct ways -- through outright nationaliza­tions and for more direct and physical controls. The right on the other hand has put more emphasis on the mixture of the state and individual com­ponents of the economy, with overall state cont­rol being accomplished through less direct means;

-- although the Labor Party as a whole accepts US domination of the western bloc the right wing has always been more compliant than the left which has stood for a more ‘independent’ line -- during the immediate post-war period a section of the left vigorously fought US policy and argued for the creation of a ‘third force’ to counter Russia on the one hand and the dictator­ship of the US over Britain on the other;

-- in front of the workers the left has tended to emphasize the class nature of society far more than the right. For example, they argue far more for ‘industrial democracy’ and workers’ control -- ideas from which the right has tended to shrink.

These ideological currents distributed through the entire Labor Party and trade union apparatus with their relative strengths and concentra­tion being determined by a combination of factors. These include:

-- in a general way, the objective situation reg­arding the economic and military problems confron­ting British capital and the pressure from the working class;

-- the relative proximities of different sections of this apparatus to the centre of the state machine;

-- the specific functions served by different parts of the apparatus -- for example, while both the constituency Labor Parties and the trade unions exist for the service of British capital, the tasks they have to perform are not identical;

-- the vulnerability of different parts of the apparatus to electoral pressures.

With these differences between the major ideolo­gical currents existing throughout this apparatus we can understand why different factions have dom­inated the party and the unions at different times and what the arguments between them have meant.

16. The composition of the post-war Labor gov­ernment was determined by the needs to comply with the severe economic and military dictates of the US, to ensure that strong mechanisms of state control over the economy were maintained, and to impose an austerity program on the working class. The party and the unions were dominated by the right wing, a coloring which had come about not least because of the fact that the British bourgeoisie dominated a crushed working class through the thirties and during the war. The Attlee administration therefore corresponded well to the situation:

-- it consolidated the state control achieved in the war years in a way which avoided too much resistance from the still-powerful sections of the private bourgeoisie. In this respect the government also had to restrict the nationaliza­tion program to an extent tolerable to the US. The US bourgeoisie put restrictions on the natio­nalization process through the conditions for the receipt of Marshall Aid, as they perceived such British state moves as a possible source of restraint on their own export program:

-- in a period of acute rivalry with Russia, the Attlee government agreed to the maintenance of strong military capacities in Europe, particularly in Germany;

-- although the balance of class forces was well in the favor of the bourgeoisie the government still saw the need to mystify the workers by sell­ing austerity with the idea that the country was being rebuilt with a clear goal of raising work­ers’ living standards. To manage the ‘welfare state’ a representative of the left, Bevan, was chosen as Minister of Health. This use of the left was strengthened further after a few years when one of its main spokesmen, Bevan, was made Minister of Labor.

17. In the period of opposition during the fifties and early sixties a redistribution of forces took place within the Labor Party and the union apparatus. In the early fifties there was a strengthening of the left in the constit­uency parties, largely over the question of foreign policy and rearmament. As the threat of the third world war receded, the left had argued against the continuation of high military expen­diture (exacerbated by Germany’s reduced support to the British forces based there) and the con­sequences of US military policy in the Far East. There, expenditures were too onerous for the economy and the left’s resistance to the US’ strictures on Britain was growing. However, in the leadership of the trade union apparatus the strength of the right remained as the low level of class struggle provided little basis for the left to develop.

In the middle and late fifties the picture began to change. The gradual improvement in the econo­mic situation produced a general electoral swing to the right which put enormous pressures on the PLP to shift in the same direction in order to maintain its electoral appeal. The response to these pressures was best expressed through the Gaitskell faction of the party, which by 1960 was arguing at the party conference for a re­writing of the party program. The Gaitskell faction wanted to discard Clause 4 -- ie the party’s theoretical commitment to the nationaliza­tions of the whole means of production. This, of course, met with intense opposition from the left, not only in the constituency parties but also in the unions, in which had been developing; a shift to the left throughout the latter half of the fifties. In contrast to the early years of the decade a higher level of class struggle was developing. This was expressed through a substantial growth in unofficial strikes against which the entrenched right wing of the union machine could not really make the most effective stand. The left therefore began to make more headway. The first major landmark in its progress was with the election of Cousins in 1956 of the TGWU (Transport and General Workers’ Union) after the death of Deakin. This leftward movement in the leadership of the major unions continued into the sixties as Scanlon, Jones and others came to prominence, replacing those such as Deakin, Lowther and Williamson.

The late fifties and early sixties was a period of intense turbulence inside the Labor Party. The left in the party and the unions were strong enough to defeat the efforts of Gaitskell to abandon Clause 4 at the 1960 conference. At the same conference the left also managed to push through a resolution calling for British unilat­eral nuclear disarmament, though this decision was reversed the following year. Although the right still dominated the party, the left had nonetheless strengthened its position substan­tially. It was with this mixture of forces active in the party that Wilson (who took the leadership after Gaitskell’s death) came to power in 1964.

18. The general goals of the Wilson administra­tion have already been outlined, including those which focused on the working class. Economic difficulties, particularly relating to the strength of sterling, confronted this government almost immediately, and therefore made it feel the need to draw up a program to attack the working class. This was to be achieved by the imposition of a concerted policy to control wages and to deal with the unofficial strikes through legislation. It was hoped that strikes could be better controlled more closely by legally binding the unions to the government. To this end, the Donovan Commission was set up in 1965 to provide the justification for the proposals which appeared in In Place of Strife in 1969. This approach was a direct reflection of the strong Gaitskellite presence in the govern­ment, and shows just how out-of-tune this adminis­tration was with the needs of the unions, which actually had to deal with the workers’ struggle. Consequently, the Seamens’ strike of 1966, rather than being seen as a warning about the need for a more flexible approach to the unions, merely stiffened the government’s resolve to act in a more rigid way towards the unions. Under the pressure of the workers’ militancy a break took place between the unions and the government across the ideological ‘fault line’. In the event the government had to back down and accept ‘voluntary’ restraint by the unions. Unable to deal with the workers’ struggle and split by the whole argument with the unions, the govern­ment fell in the 1970 General Election.

19. The main concern of the whole bourgeoisie in the subsequent period of the Heath government was the struggle of the workers. This government’s ability to deal with the situation was no better than that of the previous Labor team -- yet it was the best the Tories could find as it followed policies of the left-wing of the party. Making the same mistakes as the previous Labor govern­ment, it passed an Industrial Relations Act which the unions fought.

In opposition, the Labor Party and the union machine regrouped their forces, with two major accomplishments:

-- a significant strengthening of the left wing took place;

-- formal organizational links were made between the TUC and the Labor Party through a Liaison Committee in an effort to avoid a repeat perfor­mance of the previous years’ events where they did not function in concert.

Heath’s collapse in front of the unyielding mili­tancy of the miners in 1974 brought Labor back to power, albeit narrowly. But in the course of the election the unions and the Labor Party were able to function together and dragoon the workers to the ballot box.

20. Under the new Labor government the consoli­dation of the previous year’s work continued and produced:

-- a government with stronger representation for the left;

-- a ‘social contract’ which enabled the govern­ment and the unions to face the workers together in order to impose the austerity and discipline which the crisis-ridden economy demanded.

Because of their inexperience at these levels of militancy, the workers’ perspectives for the struggle were very limited, and together with the fact that the government and unions were again working together against them, the workers’ struggle ebbed, as it had begun to ebb in other advanced capitals. In the subsequent phase of quiescence of class struggle austerity was imposed harder and harder.

Though there was a shift to the left in the new Wilson government and even more so under Callag­han, it was tempered by the need both to pay attention to those interests among the British bourgeoisie who feared too far a movement to the left and to allay fears of the US bourgeoisie. In addition, the drive for a further move to the left was rendered unnecessary by the reflux in the struggle of the workers.

However, in the context of the resurgence of class struggle since the end of 1978, the pressures have again built up for a leftward shift in the policies and membership of the PLP. Thrown out of office in May 1979 because of their inability to maintain their austerity program on an increasingly militant working class, Labor is once again in the role of the opposition party and once again in the throes of a faction fight to equip itself for the coming turmoil by contin­uing its leftward shift.

21. The major conclusions we can draw concerning the roles of the Labor and Conservative Parties are:

-- the Labor Party is the most appropriate party for the overall defense of the interests of British capital -- not only for the present con­juncture, but for the historical period;

-- the maneuvers of the Labor Party in the face of the problems of British capital must be considered in conjunction with those of the trade unions. Over the past two decades we can see that the indispensable ideological and organiza­tional links between the different parts of the ‘Labor movement’ have been greatly strengthened;

-- the manner in which the Labor Party and the unions carry out their tasks is determined to a great extent by the parliamentary framework which the British bourgeoisie has evolved over the years. Consequently, they do not have a perman­ent position in government and their attack on the proletariat is geared according to whether they are in power or in opposition. Either way, this part of the state apparatus is the most deadly for the workers because it has evolved in the recognition of the proletariat as capital’s gravedigger.

The balance of class forces

22. The change in the relative strengths of the two major classes in society since World War II has been of historic proportions. That event marked the apex of the bourgeoisie’s class power, and the nadir of the proletariat’s. Yet today the proletariat does not merely stand in the way of further world war but is showing through its defiance and resistance to austerity that the historic course is once more towards revolution.

The fact that World War II was not followed almost immediately by a third between Russia and the US was because the controlled reconstruction of the world economy attenuated the inter-imperialist rivalries sufficiently to create a pause in the ever-present tendency towards war in the epoch of capitalist decadence. As the reconstruction of the economy took place at such a global level it provided a far longer period of economic stimulation than had been possible after World War I. This extended period -- which lasted more than a generation -- has allowed the working class to recover from the prostrating effects of the long period of counter-revolution.

While these assessments about the historical course come from a global perspective on the balance of class forces, it is nonetheless possi­ble, and necessary, to examine the actual experience of the change of course in specific countries.

23. During the whole period of counter-revolution the workers never stopped struggling. For all the weakness of the class its militancy never died, not even during the war. In Britain, despite the fact that all strike action was declared illegal by Order 1305 there were many wildcats, especially by miners and engineers who were among the most brutally exploited during the war. Vicious propaganda was leveled against them; on the eve of the apprentice engineers’ strike they were threatened with conscription if they didn’t go back to work; the Betteshanger miners were imprisoned -- although the strike was so militant the state bureaucrats had to contin­ue to negotiate with the strikers in gaol. None­theless, the overwhelming advantage was of course with the bourgeoisie, which achieved a total mobilization of the population for the war effort, especially at the point of production where the union apparatus and the now-flourishing shop stewards’ movement attained levels of exploita­tion which were the envy of the rest of the world’s bourgeoisie.

In the period following the war -- under the Labor government -- these conditions of brutal austerity were maintained. (Rationing, for example, did not end until the mid-fifties.) The workers’ response was still fragmented but there were pockets of strong resistance such as the miners and dockers whose strikes led to more failings and prosecutions by the government using the wartime laws. Still the weight of the bour­geoisie was enormously strong.

During the early fifties the class struggle tend­ed to remain at a low intensity as the austerity measures were steadily relaxed and some portion of the ‘benefits’ were won by the workers, inclu­ding the maintenance of full employment. All the same, the trade unions continued to support the Labor and Conservative governments’ policies of ‘wage restraint’, it was not until 1956 that the TUC withdrew its formal support for such policies, thereby giving an indication of the growing resistance developing among the workers.

24. The latter half of the fifties brought a substantial rise in strikes which particularly concerned the bourgeoisie because they tended to be concentrated in key sectors with dockers, electricians and car workers in the lead. The bourgeoisie used several tactics to deal with the wage claims and strikes:

-- prolonging the ‘negotiations’ between the unions and the employers to delay strikes for wage claims;

-- channeling these struggles into the inter-union rivalries over demarcation which were endemic in the late fifties (and were related to the process of concentration going on in the apparatus of the unions at the time);

-- the granting of higher wages which the expansion of the economy still permitted with only a slow erosion through the relatively low inflation rate of the time.

Through the sixties the pressure on the workers increased and palliatives could only be found in return for more and more productivity, heightening the rate of exploitation to levels which later became explosive. At the same time, there were several, industries which underwent enormous run­downs in manning levels caused by the introduc­tion elf new technology. Where these factors were most prominent, so were the highest levels of militancy to appear -- in the mines, car plants, docks, railways, steel, etc.

Thus by the mid-sixties, just prior to the onset of the open crisis, there were certain conditions which were to affect the conduct of the coming battles between the major classes. The working class had been given time by the reconstruction to recover from its past horrendous defeats but had experienced only low levels of class struggle which could be contained within a framework of economic expansion. The bourgeoisie too had little recent experience of high levels of class struggle, and in addition, its primary apparatus for mystification and control of the workers -- the Labor Party and trade union apparatus were not fully synchronized, and had pronounced ideological differences.

25. With the onset of the crisis and its intensification of class struggle, the economic, political and social equilibrium were all destroyed. The first wave of proletarian militancy in Britain had several noteworthy characteristics:

-- it lasted for a long time – from 1968-74 – with the phases of rise and dissipation being quite slow;

-- it drew into itself, at one level or another, the whole of the class and contrasted dramatically in this respect with the struggles of the forties, fifties and early sixties;

-- despite the convulsions into which society was thrown by these strikes, the struggle never expressed itself on the political level.

The reaction of the bourgeoisie was first to retreat, to regroup its strongest forces; and then, when the struggle was ebbing, to counter­attack:

-- the ‘retreat’ was a stepping back from the direct confrontation against the workers as their upsurge continued. Recognizing the dangers, the bourgeoisie limited the use of the repressive arms of the state against the workers. The trade union leaders had to back off too, as in the early phase they became less and less able to hold the workers at bay. The most dramatic example of this was the 1970 picketing of the NUM (National Union of Mineworkers) headquarters (guarded by police) by furious miners against the union bosses who were trying to break their wildcat. Such warnings were clear and the unions were forced to allow the class to ‘let off steam’ for a while. It was in this period that the Wilson government fell.

-- the Heath government recognized many of the dangers, but not as clearly as the left of the bourgeoisie; it drifted down the path of confron­tation and in so doing put itself forward as the personification of the anti-working class move­ment in society, to the benefit of the Labor Party and the unions which were thus able to organize the biggest mobilization of workers since the twenties in the fight against the Industrial Relations Act. During this period there was the regroupment of forces in the Labor Party and the trade unions that we described earlier. In the meantime the task was given to the shop stewards to ‘go with the class’ so that they could later grasp the reins and slow the struggle down. They concentrated on keeping strikes isolated from each other, and from other sections of the class not on strike -- a strategy epitomized by the wave of factory occupations in 1971 and 1972. The use of the 3-day week and the General. Election in February 1974 to break the miners’ strike permitted a now-strengthened Labor Government to face the class again;

-- the counter--attack began in earnest after the Election, against a now-ebbing wave of militancy. Working far more closely together than they had been able to do in the sixties, the Labor gov­ernment and the unions built up to a crescendo the campaign for the social contract, sealing it in July 1975. After conceding relatively high percentage wage settlements for a time, the Labor government once more returned to its natural role: covering itself with sanctimonious concern for the national interest, it became again the party of austerity.

26. The austerity measures held fast in Britain and were a model for the bourgeoisie of the west­ern world. As the reflux settled, austerity became tougher. The repercussion at the ideological level was that the formal rules no longer had to be agreed to -- in 1977, after two years of the social contract, the pretence of the ending of an agreement was put forward by the unions with great gusto. Instead, ‘guidelines’ were adhered to -- with the objective being to maintain austerity and to reduce the association between the unions and the measures of austerity.

However, while this has been the intention, it is also true that the austerity program has eroded the credibility of the unions and the left. Consequently, the bourgeoisie is faced with the problem that the use of its left face today undermines further shifts to the left in future. This has already been seen throughout 1979 with stronger challenges being made to the authority of the unions and shop stewards, and with a widespread indifference to the maneuver­ings of the Labor Party being exhibited by the workers.

27. The current strike wave, which erupted during the 1978-79 winter, shows that the working class is beginning to emerge from these past years of reflux and reassert itself on its own class terrain. And if the major left fac­tions of the bourgeoisie, the Labor Party, has been removed to the position of ‘loyal opposit­ion’ the better to refurbish itself then this is not because of a strengthening but because of a weakening of the ruling class in the face of an increasingly combative proletariat. Truly, the workers’ struggle exacerbates the political crisis of the ruling class.

Once more the struggle of the proletariat has become the axis of the entire social situation.

***********************

This text has traced only the general lines of the evolution of the situation in Britain since World War II. It has covered a period in which the balance of class forces has been predominantly in favor of the bourgeoisie, and has outlined the general context from which the future, titanic movements of the proletariat will emerge. The specific way in which the current, second wave of class struggle since the onset of the open crisis in 1968 is developing is described in ‘The Report of the British Situation’ in World Revolution, no.26.

Marlowe

Britain

Book traversal links for The evolution of the British situation since World War 2 (part two)

  • ‹ The Mexican Left, 1938: The reactionary character of nationalizations in the imperialist phase of capitalism
  • Up
Home
International Communist Current
Workers of the world, unite!

Footer menu

  • Basic positions of the ICC
  • Contact