I realise some ICC comrades have already responded to the above article briefly on the leftcom site but there have been a few further comments since. My own comments were under the name 'proletarian' which I would appreciate someone responding to. I will reiterate here no matter what theoretical differences there are between Left Communists including the former IBRP and ex-ICC comrades etc matters should be approached and discussed in documents and on-line (Libcom.org for example) by all in a comradely manner. Despite what some ex-ICC comrades, Left Communists and others say I get the impression and it is my opinion through reading discussions on Libcom regarding the IBRP and in texts etc that the criticisms (non-theoretical ones mostly)) in the main against the ICC come across more from the people themselves and not the ICC! I am talking about manner of discussions, misrepresenting what people say/do, slander, childishness etc. It really does put people off furthering an interest in Left Communism and ALL the organisations.
20 April, 2011 - 15:29#1
Marxism or Idealism - Our Differences with the ICC